Random Review #2: World Finest #176, June 1968
Last time out we looked back at a Marvel comic from the late Sixties, this time we’ll try our luck with DC.
“The Superman-Batman Split!”
Cary Bates, writer
Neal Adams, artist
Dick Giordano, inker
The splash page of World’s Finest #176 is split vertically right down the middle. On the left, a shadowy figure has dissolved Clark Kent’s clothing, revealing him as Superman; and on the right, a similar scene depicts another darkened figure confronting Batman in the Bat-Cave and calling him by his real name.
The story opens with Clark Kent visiting the mansion of movie star Ronald Jason, a favorite of his for years. Jason interrupts the tour of his home to reveal that he knows Clark is secretly Superman, and exposes Clark’s costume with a chemical bomb that dissolves his outer clothing.
“Jason” himself then unmasks, revealing himself as Dur, a blue-skinned alien from “the fifth planet in the Sirius solar system”. He claims he’s come to Earth to hide from the assassin(s) who murdered the planet’s leader, whom Dur is scheduled to succeed after a 10-day period of mourning. Dur says he chose Earth because his people have studied our world from afar for many years and know its languages and customs. These long-distance studies are also how Dur knows Superman’s secret. Dur says he has chosen to reveal his own secret to Superman because he has reason to believe the killer(s) have tracked him to Earth to finish him off. Superman whisks Dur away to the safety of the Fortress of Solitude, but has to leave him there alone to undertake a mission of mercy to a distant galaxy.
“Later that same day”, Batman discovers a blue-skinned alien intruder in the Bat-Cave. The intruder introduces himself as Tiron, a law-enforcement officer from another planet. He says he has come to Earth by way of a molecular transporter, in pursuit of a dangerous criminal from his world. Tiron asks for Batman’s help in apprehending the fugitive, whose name is Dur.
Batman wants to bring in Superman for help, but Tiron vetoes the plan because he has learned that Dur has already tricked Superman into aiding him. Instead, Batman and Tiron fly in the Bat-Plane to Stanhope College to recruit the aid of Supergirl. The Maid of Might suggests that if Superman is indeed aiding Dur, the most likely place to hide Dur would be the Fortress of Solitiude. Bats and Supergirl set out for the Arctic, but Tiron elects to stay behind to rendezvous with some other agents from his world.
At the Fortress, Supergirl uses her Kryptonian strength to heft the huge key that unlocks the great door, but Superman arrives to warn them off. Supergirl throws the key at her cousin while Batman slips inside to search for the alien criminal. Batman gets the drop on Dur, but Superman has already overpowered Supergirl and tossed her away. Superman catches Batman in a cage from his interplanetary zoo and escapes with Dur…both heroes believe the other has been duped. Supergirl returns and frees Batman. They decide to contact Tiron and bring him up to speed.
Superman scoops out a cave for Dur to use as a new hiding place, informing his alien ally that he’ll need help if he’s to hold off both Batman and Supergirl again. Superman heads to Gotham City Park and attracts the attention of Batgirl (whose secret identity he doesn’t know) by posing as a statue from the park come to life. They return to Dur’s cave and, after hearing them out, Batgirl decides to join their cause.
“The next day, in Metropolis”, Robin confronts Jimmy Olsen in his apartment and they head to their own headquarters, the Eyrie, to investigate why their adult chums are at odds. Using the secret, unauthorized video feeds they’ve established in both the Bat-Cave and the Fortress, the lads make a startling discovery about the aliens. They rush to alert their pals of the truth, but are waylaid by knockout gas and fall unconscious in their own base.
Meanwhile, Batman, Supergirl, and Tiron have traced Superman’s Justice League of America signal device to the cave where he has hidden Dur. Donning kryptonite gloves, Batman sets out to battle Superman while Supergirl slips around back to retrieve Dur. Tiron lures Superman out with a ray gun blast, then Batman strikes unexpectedly and takes Superman to the ground. Batman lands a solid green-K punch on his old friend.
By then, Supergirl has reached the rear of the cave and is slugging her way through the solid rock when Batgirl catches her unawares with a thick spray of “synthetic adhesive”. Supergirl frees herself with her heat vision.
Batman spots Batgirl falling from her perch atop the cave and, with Superman weakened by the kryptonite, he has to break off to save her. That leaves Batman vulnerable to Superman’s counter attack, a makeshift lasso fashioned from Superman’s cape, that allows the Man of Steel to incapacitate Batman without coming within range of the kryptonite.
Suddenly Tiron collapses. He announces that he is dying, and reveals himself to really be Ronald Jason after all. In fact, Jason is both Tiron and Dur! He explains that his brother Desmond Jason, a brilliant scientist, had recently made some unique breakthroughs including a fabric-dissolving chemical bomb, a miniature jet-pack, an artificial, lighter-than-air radioactive element, and, most astonishingly of all, voice print scans which revealed the true identities of both Superman and Batman.
Unfortunately, the radioactive element was highly unstable, and went critical as Ronald and Desmond were touring the laboratory. Desmond was killed, and Ronald was dosed with fatal radiation levels. With his own death sentence hanging over his head, Ronald salvaged his brother’s inventions and decided to make his last days the most exciting of his entire life. Using his own expertise with makeup and disguise, he crafted his alien masks and uniforms, then set his hoax in motion. He used the jet-pack to travel back and forth between identities, and spent his last days on Earth giving “the greatest performance of all-time”.
As Jason passes, Robin and Jimmy Olsen finally arrive, excited with their discovery. Superman confesses that it was he who gassed them, though, because he knew all along he was being tricked. Jason gave himself away with his choice of the aliens’ homeworld, which Superman had once explored and knew to be uninhabited. He used his x-ray vision to learn who was truly behind the alien mask, and devices in the Fortress of Solitude diagnosed Jason’s fatal illness. Superman and Batman opted to play along, but left Batgirl and Supergirl in the dark so Jason’ act could be considered a success.
In the final panel, all six heroes gather to pay their respects to Ronald Jason, and to treasure the private performance he gave for their benefit.
In those days, World’s Finest books included a reprint back-up story under the “Editor’s Round Table” imprint. The story chosen for this issue is the second ever appearance of John Jones, the Manhunter from Mars, from Detective Comics #226, December 1955. In “The Case of the Magic Baseball”, John is tasked with protecting an aspiring big league pitcher from blackmailers threatening to reveal his criminal record. The pitcher, Big Bob Michaels, genuinely wants to go straight, so John uses the vast powers at his disposal (including Martian "molecular hypnosis") to control the game and prevent Michaels from succumbing to the gangsters’ pressure. In the end, Big Bob not only pitches a shutout but also hits the game-winning home run, and John invisibly nabs the crooks who inevitably confess to their wrongdoings.
WOW! This is one of my all-time favorites issues of World’s Finest. Everything is just right in the tale of doomed actor Ronald Jason and the greatest performance of his career. Superman, Batman, Supergirl, Batgirl, Robin, and Jimmy Olsen all in story? Readers certainly got their 12 cents worth. The Adams art was fantastic, particularly the panels where Batman catches the falling Batgirl and the one with Supergirl smashing the giant Fortress key into Superman. Pitting the heroes against each other was a nice touch by Bates, too, especially the way he paired off Supes/Batgirl and Bats/Supergirl. The scene wherein Batman pretends to hammer Superman with gloves made fron green kryptonite is oddly prophetic. Comics fans may recall a similar, non-faked scene played out in the pages of Frank Miller's 1986 mini-series, The Dark Knight Returns.
The Martian Manhunter back-up tale was fun, especially for a baseball fan like me. As I mentioned in my “Was the Flash First?” blog entry awhile back, John in those days was much more of a detective with a gimmick than a super hero, but what a gimmick he had! He manages to pack no less than nine super-powered feats into the six page story.
Bottom Line: Great story + great art + great cast = Great Book!